Step-by-Step Guide: Crispy Air Fryer Fingerling Potatoes Perfected

You’ve got an air fryer and a bag of fingerling potatoes, and you’re ready to create a culinary masterpiece. But how do you ensure those little spuds come out crispy on the outside and tender on the inside? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered.

In this article, we’ll guide you through the process of air frying fingerling potatoes to perfection. You’ll learn the best temperature settings, cooking times, and a few flavor-boosting tips. So, get your apron on and let’s turn those fingerlings into a gourmet side dish that’ll impress everyone at your dinner table.

Key Takeaways

  • Fingerling potatoes are ideal for air frying due to their thin skin, small oblong shape, and firm texture, which allows for uniform heating and a crispy exterior.
  • Selecting high-quality fingerling potatoes of similar size ensures even cooking. Avoid potatoes with signs of decay or a green hue, as the latter indicates presence of solanine, a toxic substance.
  • Thorough washing, drying, and proper seasoning (basic or experimental) are vital steps before air frying. Remember, dry potatoes yield a better air fried outcome.
  • Preheating the air fryer, arranging the potatoes in a single layer in the basket, and setting the correct cooking time and temperature are key to achieving perfect air fried fingerling potatoes.
  • A variety of dipping sauces, toppings, and main courses can be paired with fingerling potatoes to enhance their flavor. Consider garlic aioli, rosemary or truffle oil, and protein-rich foods like grilled salmon or roast chicken.
  • To achieve a crispy texture, soak the potatoes in ice cold water to remove starch and use high smoke point oils like avocado or canola. Ensure even cooking by selecting similar-sized potatoes, arranging them properly in a single layer, and shaking them halfway through cooking for uniform exposure to heat.

Understanding Fingerling Potatoes

After discussing the method of air frying fingerling potatoes, it’s logical to take a step back and gain insights on the subject matter itself: fingerling potatoes. Let’s dive into their special properties that make them an ideal fit for air frying and the process to select the best ones for cooking.

Why They’re Perfect for Air Frying

Fingerling potatoes bear a thin skin, thereby simplifying the entry of heat and easing the cooking process. Their small, oblong shape ensures uniformity when it comes to heat distribution. A significant feature lies in their firm texture, which remains unaltered during cooking, providing the perfect contrast to the crispy exterior you achieve with an air fryer. On the flavor front, those fingerling potatoes hold a slightly nutty, buttery taste, which means less dependence on additional flavorings.

Selecting the Best Fingerling Potatoes

Picking high-quality fingerling potatoes is as important as the cooking method. Look for firm, smooth spuds with no signs of decay, cuts, or bruises. Avoid those with a green hue since it denotes an excess of solanine – a toxic substance that emerges due to inappropriate storage or overexposure to sunlight. Go for potatoes of similar size to ensure even cooking during the air frying process. A mix of larger and smaller potatoes might result in uneven cooking, where smaller potatoes become overcooked while larger ones still undercooked. So, select wisely to ensure deliciously perfect air fried fingerling potatoes.

Preparing Your Fingerling Potatoes for Air Frying

This section tackles two crucial steps in getting your fingerling potatoes absolutely ready for air frying: washing and drying, and seasoning options.

Washing and Drying

Begin by thoroughly washing your selected fingerling potatoes. A soft-bristle brush ensures a proper cleanse, yet this remains gentle to the thin skin of the potatoes. Rinse them under running water – tap water suffices, and completely remove any dirt or debris.

Once washed, lay out the potatoes on a flat surface, such as a clean kitchen towel or a rack. This helps in air drying them, effectively getting rid of excess moisture. A dry surface guarantee reliable air frying, yielding potatoes with a crispy exterior and soft interior. Remember, it’s essential to have the potatoes completely dried before moving to the next step, the seasoning!

Seasoning Options

Seasoning gives an exciting flavor profile to your fingerling potatoes, complementing their inherent nutty taste. So, after drying, prepare to season your potatoes.

For a basic seasoning, a mix of salt and freshly ground black pepper provides a straightforward yet delicious taste. But don’t hesitate to experiment with other flavors and blends! Smokey flavors, for instance, can be achieved by sprinkling smoked paprika. Herbs like rosemary or thyme bring a satisfying earthiness. A touch of garlic powder or cayenne pepper adds pungent or spicy notes. Don’t forget, a bit of olive oil ensures even coating of seasonings.

Keep in mind, after applying the seasoning of your choice, toss your potatoes gently to ensure a consistent flavor profile in every bite. You’re now ready to cook your seasoned, fingerling potatoes in the air fryer! These preparations will diligently lead you to a delightful crispy, tender, and flavorful fingerling potato dish.

The Air Frying Process

This part of the article delves particularly into the aspect of air frying fingerling potatoes. Key steps involved in the air frying process are thoroughly discussed, from preheating your air fryer to arranging the potatoes in the basket, as well as determining the optimal time and temperature settings.

Preheating Your Air Fryer

Preheating the air fryer plays a critical role in achieving the desired consistency of fingerling potatoes. Most models require preheating at a temperature of 204 degrees Celsius (400 degrees Fahrenheit) for about five minutes. Remember, preheating isn’t just for ovens, an air fryer benefits from the same principle, setting the stage for even heat distribution.

Arranging the Potatoes in the Basket

Once preheated, it’s time to arrange the potatoes in the basket. For better heat circulation, spread them in a single layer avoiding any overlap. Remember, overcrowding the basket might interfere with your quest for achieving crispy, evenly cooked potatoes. Tools like silicone dividers can assist in ensuring each potato has its own cooking space.

Optimal Time and Temperature Settings

After arranging the potatoes, setting the correct cooking time and temperature ensures the perfect outcome. Typically, air frying fingerling potatoes at 204 degrees Celsius provides the optimal balance between crispy exteriors and tender interiors. For bite-sized potatoes, try a 15-minute cooking time, shaking halfway. If your potatoes are larger, they might require up to 20 minutes. Keep an eye on them, as all air fryers differ in power and potato sizes can vary.

Integrating these steps breathes life into the fingerling potatoes, transitioning them from a raw tuber into a crispy, indulgent delight. The attention to details here, from preheating your air fryer to arranging the potatoes and setting the optimal time and temperature, greatly influences the quality of the final dish.

Serving Suggestions for Air Fried Fingerling Potatoes

When serving air fried fingerling potatoes, consider pairing them with a variety of dipping sauces, toppings, and main courses. This way, you further enhance the potatoes’ nutty flavor and crispy texture.

Dipping Sauces and Toppings

Leverage air fried fingerling potatoes by complementing them with dipping sauces. Thick and creamy sauces, like garlic aioli, lend an earthy tang, while spicy ketchup imparts a subtle heat that contrasts with the potatoes’ sweetness. For a zesty kick, consider lemon herb tahini dressing.

Toppings for air fried fingerling potatoes run the gamut from simple to sophisticated. Fresh herbs, such as rosemary, thyme, or parsley, accentuate their natural flavor. A dusting of thermalized Parmesan cheese not only provides a umami punch but also a crunchy texture. Truffle oil infuses the potatoes with a luxurious and deeper flavor, while a squeeze of fresh lemon juice brightens its taste.

Pairing with Main Courses

Pairing air fried fingerling potatoes with appropriate main courses enhances your dining experience. Since the potatoes already have a rich, robust flavor, they pair well with protein-rich foods. Examples include grilled salmon, roast chicken, or pan-fried steak.

For a vegetarian feast, combine the air fried potatoes with ratatouille or a hearty salad of mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, olives, and a lemon garlic dressing. Their hearty presence balances any meal, making air fried fingerling potatoes not just a side, but a star in your menu.

Tips for Perfect Air Fryer Fingerling Potatoes

Now that you’ve gotten the grasp of preparing and serving fingerling potatoes, let’s delve deeper into the refining touches that’ll bring your air-fried potatoes to perfection. Here, we’ll focus on two significant aspects: Achieving that much-desired crispy texture and ensuring even cooking for all your potatoes.

Achieving Crispy Texture

Attaining a crispy exterior on your air-fried fingerling potatoes relies on handling pre-cooking procedures with precision. Contrary to common beliefs, soaking potatoes in ice cold water for about 30 minutes to an hour helps remove excess starch, thereby promoting a crispy finish. After soaking, ensure to pat the potatoes dry. Excess water leads to steaming rather than air frying, preventing the exterior from becoming crispy.

The choice of oil also plays a crucial role in achieving this crispy texture. High smoke point oils such as avocado oil, grape seed oil, or canola oil are ideal as they withstand the high temperatures of the air fryer without breaking down. Generally, a light drizzle suffices, as excess oil won’t necessarily make your potatoes crispier, it’s more likely to make them greasier.

Ensuring Even Cooking

Uniform cooking of your fingerling potatoes in the air fryer entails careful organization and mindful consideration of cooking procedures. Opt for potatoes of similar sizes, as different sized potatoes tend to cook at different rates, resulting in an uneven end product.

How you position your potatoes in the air fryer also impacts their cooking. It’s optimal to place them in a single layer in the fryer basket, spaced apart to allow proper circulation of hot air. Overlapping or stacking potatoes blocks air circulation, leading to some potatoes being undercooked while others are overcooked.

Lastly, don’t forget to toss or shake your potatoes halfway through cooking. This simple yet vital step ensures all sides of the potatoes are exposed to the hot air equally, facilitating even cooking and the formation of a uniformly crispy exterior.


You’ve got the insider tips and tricks to perfect air fried fingerling potatoes. It’s all about the prep, from choosing the right potatoes to soaking them in ice water. Remember, high smoke point oils are your best friend when it comes to achieving that sought-after crispy texture. Make sure to arrange your potatoes in a single layer and give them a good toss halfway through cooking. Don’t forget the toppings and dips – they’re the cherry on top of your delicious, crispy fingerling potatoes. With these steps in your cooking arsenal, you’re set to serve up some seriously tasty air fried fingerlings. So go ahead, fire up that air fryer and let the cooking magic happen. Happy cooking!

Cooking fingerling potatoes in an air fryer is a quick way to achieve a crispy, golden-brown finish. Healthful Blondie recommends preheating the air fryer to 400°F, then roasting the potatoes for 20 minutes while shaking the basket halfway for an even crisp. Allrecipes suggests cooking for just 15 minutes to ensure the interior remains tender and creamy. Alternatively, Foolproof Living’s guide advises shaking the tray halfway through and seasoning with herbs after cooking for extra flavor.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main focus of this article?

The article focuses on a detailed guide for air frying fingerling potatoes, including choosing appropriate potatoes, preparing them right, and serving suggestions.

Why is choosing similar-sized potatoes important?

Choosing similarly sized potatoes ensures even cooking. Larger potatoes could remain undercooked while smaller ones might burn if cooked simultaneously.

What steps should I follow in preparing the potatoes?

Begin with washing and drying the potatoes, followed by seasoning. You may soak them in ice water to remove excess starch for a crispier texture.

What type of oil should I use for air frying?

For air frying, use oils with a high smoke point, since they handle the heat of an air fryer better and don’t break down into harmful compounds.

How should I position the potatoes in the air fryer?

It’s recommended to position the potatoes in a single layer. Halfway through cooking, toss the potatoes to ensure uniform cooking and crispiness.

What type of serving suggestions are provided in the article?

The article suggests serving air-fried fingerling potatoes with various dips and toppings to enhance the flavor and make the meal more enjoyable.